HomeSample Page

Sample Page Title


Google Pixel 10 Pro XL vs Xiaomi 17 Ultra

Robert Triggs / Android Authority

I really like Pixels, and the Pixel 6 Professional marked my conversion to Google’s ecosystem, thanks in no small half to its extremely highly effective triple rear digicam. Computational pictures has confirmed its worth over time and stays a core a part of Google’s gross sales pitch for the Pixel 10 sequence.

Nevertheless, for a product line lauded for its picture seize capabilities, I’m discovering it more and more laborious to rank Pixels close to the highest of the pack. Sure, they’re nonetheless unbelievably dependable at fundamental point-and-shoot, and on the similar time, a great eye can get hold of breathtaking outcomes from what is kind of modest {hardware} on paper. I’m not denying that Google’s components is sweet, however nice by trendy requirements? I’m not as satisfied as I as soon as was.

I’ve more and more left my most up-to-date Pixel on the shelf in favor of bodily bigger smartphone digicam packages or my trusty mirrorless. After spending most likely an excessive amount of time pixel-peeping, I’ve turn into conscious about Google’s processing artifacts and have concluded that I actually don’t like blowing these footage up. Whereas I can overlook the grainy shadows, mottled low-light particulars, and overly-sharp portraits for a fast social publish, that’s not what I actually need when spending doubtlessly $1,000 or extra on a cellphone primarily to take footage with.

By comparability, I’ve had the Xiaomi 17 Extremely in hand not too long ago. After taking it out for a spin alongside my Pixel 10 Professional XL, I’d by no means return to a Pixel till Google critically overhauls its {hardware}.

Do you suppose Pixels are among the many greatest telephones for pictures?

21 votes

Not that the 2 telephones aren’t comparable for general-purpose pictures. Each provide excellent dynamic vary, wealthy and real looking colours, and a good quantity of element from their principal and zoom cameras. If something, the Pixel is arguably the marginally extra constant choice, with Xiaomi’s colour science often veering off into oversaturation and underexposure.

Nonetheless, peek a bit nearer on the footage, and the Pixel’s veneer shortly rubs off. Xiaomi’s newest telephoto digicam provides the cellphone a big benefit for picture high quality and suppleness, particularly if you happen to body and crop your footage as a lot as I do.

Take this instance that mixes excessive low gentle with moderate-range zoom: an actual take a look at for even devoted cameras in the marketplace, not to mention small-sensor cellphone zoom cameras. Each look OK at full body, however when it comes to element preservation, the Pixel is totally insufficient right here, even with the assistance of Evening mode. There’s important noise and smudged or lacking particulars. In the meantime, the Xiaomi 17 Extremely delivers a stage of element that even my Fuji mirrorless can’t match, fairly probably as a consequence of the usage of multi-frame processing and presumably a bit AI (there’s one thing concerning the look that’s undoubidly a bit synthetic). In any case, noise and element have persistently been a difficulty for Google, and the divide is just rising.

Pixels have been a continuing disappointment for portrait pictures.

Likewise, portraits have been a protracted working Pixel bugbear of mine for comparable causes. For all Google’s singing and dancing about Pure Tone, blemishes and textures proceed to look far too sharp at full body, but someway disappear into mush on shut inspection. This won’t matter a lot on a cellphone display, however it could possibly come again to chunk the Pixel if you happen to ever wish to print out your snaps for a photograph album or a body.

The much less stated concerning the Pixel’s bokeh blur in comparison with the pure impact of Xiaomi’s new 75mm lens, the higher. Software program simply isn’t as correct or as nice-looking as the actual factor. By comparability, I charge Xiaomi’s portrait particulars and bokeh as most likely one of the best within the enterprise, rivaling the standard I anticipate from my Fuji mirrorless.

Returning to AI and zoom, Google’s newest strategy has been to depend on AI diffusion upscaling with Professional Res Zoom to flesh out particulars at 30x and past. Alternatively, Xiaomi has embraced a bigger 200MP sensor, paired with a 75mm-100mm variable focal size lens to assist it cater to each brief and lengthy distances. The identical sensor that took the good portrait above can be a dab hand at lengthy distances too.

In my expertise, Xiaomi has a transparent benefit at 3x as a consequence of its pure optics. It’s a reasonably stage taking part in discipline taking part in round 5x and 10x, however past that, I’d give a slight edge to the Chinese language handset. Google’s AI upscaling works properly on some textures however struggles with others. In the meantime, Xiaomi’s long-range efforts are clearly not flawless, however the bigger sensor ensures its outcomes look corresponding to Google’s AI upscaling efforts in daylight.

It is powerful to see the good thing about AI zoom over higher {hardware}.

We will prolong this zoom-camera comparability to macro, too. Xiaomi’s novel lens can focus moderately shut up, leading to pure depth and bokeh with out having to stand up tremendous near the topic. Google’s 5x telephoto digicam can’t focus anyplace close to this shut, so it resorts to digital upscaling or the ultrawide digicam, which introduces perspective distortion and an absence of actual depth. Xiaomi can do ultrawide digicam macros too, however there’s no substitute for a protracted focal size to reinforce macro pictures.

And this actually is the Pixel’s downside in a nutshell. Google constructed its early fame on computational pictures, doing extra with much less, and was initially very profitable at bridging the hole and sometimes main the pack. It’s largely continued this development lately on the expense of rising {hardware} enhancements that allow not solely higher picture high quality but in addition extra versatile taking pictures choices.

Once more, to not disparage Google’s computational pictures efforts. Publicity, tone mapping, and night time pictures stay the Pixel’s strongest fits, and Google has augmented these necessities with enjoyable and helpful instruments like Add Me and Magic Editor. However for all Google’s strengths, its imaging pipeline lags the competitors in uncooked picture high quality.

In order for you footage from a smartphone that look as near lifelike as potential, together with next-level artistic flexibility, the Pixel shouldn’t be the place it’s at nowadays.

Pictures isn’t every thing, but it surely’s laborious to withstand

Google Pixel 10 Pro XL vs Xiaomi 17 Ultra cameras

Robert Triggs / Android Authority

This isn’t to say the Pixel 10 or Galaxy S26 isn’t a great handset for snapping these household occasions or documenting your travels. They’re nonetheless versatile sufficient to go well with most wants. Nevertheless, if you happen to’re a very severe photographer who will make use of cutting-edge options and calls for the head of cellular picture high quality, I feel you’ll discover way more utility with telephones just like the Xiaomi 17 Extremely. The one situation for US clients is getting their fingers on these alternate options.

After all, there’s much more that goes into making a fantastic cellphone. Whereas cutting-edge {hardware} fanatics could also be more and more turning their gaze to China’s Extremely fashions, there’s nonetheless one thing to be stated for the broader ecosystem of the Pixel or Galaxy expertise. However as a photographer-first cellphone consumer, I’m more and more questioning if that’s sufficient to maintain me coming again.

Don’t wish to miss one of the best from Android Authority?

google preferred source badge light@2xgoogle preferred source badge dark@2x

Thanks for being a part of our group. Learn our Remark Coverage earlier than posting.

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles