Why Your Prop Agency EA is Getting Detected (And What Really Works)
You got an EA. You set it up in your problem account. It ran for just a few days, possibly even made some revenue.
You then received the e-mail.
“Your account has been terminated on account of violation of our phrases of service.”
No warning. No clarification. No refund. Simply gone.
If this has occurred to you, you are not alone. And it is occurring extra typically than ever.
Prop Companies Are Getting Smarter
Two years in the past, you may run virtually any EA on a prop agency problem and no person would discover.
That is now not the case.
Prop companies have invested closely in commerce sample detection. They are not simply taking a look at whether or not you are utilizing an EA, they’re analyzing your trades throughout their complete consumer base.
And in case your trades match another person’s? Purple flag.
How They Really Detect You
Most merchants suppose detection means somebody is watching their display screen or checking if MetaTrader is operating an Knowledgeable Advisor.
That is not the way it works.
This is what prop companies really search for:
1. Similar entry instances throughout accounts
If 50 merchants all open a EURUSD BUY at 10:32:15 on the identical day, that is not a coincidence. That is an EA with one technique sending the identical sign to each consumer.
2. Matching cease loss and take revenue ranges
Your EA units SL at 20 pips and TP at 40 pips on each commerce? So does each different consumer operating the identical EA. That sample is trivial to detect.
3. Identical technique fingerprint
Each buying and selling technique has a fingerprint, the mixture of when it enters, the place it locations stops, how lengthy it holds trades, and the way it exits. When tons of of accounts share the identical fingerprint, the prop agency would not must know what EA you are utilizing. They only must see the sample.
4. Constant risk-to-reward ratios
If each single considered one of your trades has a 1:2 risk-to-reward ratio, that is a signature. Human merchants do not commerce that persistently. Algorithms do.
5. Commerce clustering
A number of accounts opening and shutting positions inside seconds of one another. Even when the entries are barely completely different, the timing sample provides it away.
Why Most EAs Fail This Check
The issue with 99% of prop agency EAs is straightforward:
Each consumer runs the very same technique.
Identical logic. Identical indicators. Identical parameters. Identical entries. Identical exits.
The EA would possibly work completely from a buying and selling perspective. The technique is perhaps worthwhile. However when 500 individuals are operating the identical code, it creates a sample that is unattainable to cover.
It would not matter how good the technique is. If it is detectable, it is ineffective on a prop agency.
What “Undetectable” Really Means
Being undetectable doesn’t suggest hiding the truth that you are utilizing an EA. Prop companies do not care about automation, lots of them encourage it.
Being undetectable means: your trades can’t be grouped with some other dealer’s trades.
Your entry logic is completely different.
Your exit logic is completely different.
Your cease loss ranges are completely different.
Your take revenue ranges are completely different.
Your commerce timing is completely different.
When a prop agency appears to be like at your account, they see a novel dealer. Not considered one of 500 operating the identical bot.
The 1,000 Mixture Strategy
That is the strategy I take advantage of, and the one I constructed into my EA.
As an alternative of 1 technique, the EA makes use of a 3-layer system:
Layer A: Entry Technique (10 choices)
When to enter, breakout, imply reversion, pullback, momentum, vary breakout, development continuation, reversal, session open, information fade, or volatility squeeze.
Layer B: Market Construction (10 choices)
learn the market, ICT ideas, energy of three, good cash, provide and demand, assist and resistance, fibonacci, pivot factors, market profile, order circulation, or liquidity zones.
Layer C: Sample Affirmation (10 choices)
What to search for, Elliott wave, divergence, harmonics, candlestick patterns, chart patterns, Wyckoff, transferring common cross, RSI extremes, MACD sign, or quantity affirmation.
10 x 10 x 10 = 1,000 distinctive combos.
Every consumer selects a special mixture. Or units it to random and lets the EA select.
The consequence: no two customers commerce alike. Totally different entries, completely different timing, completely different patterns. Zero overlap.
However It is Not Simply the Technique
A novel technique is just a part of the puzzle. There are different fingerprints that can provide you away:
Fastened risk-to-reward ratios
In case your EA at all times targets 1:3, that is a sample. My system randomizes the R:R between 1:2 and 1:5 on each commerce. Generally you’re taking 1:2, generally 1:5. Similar to a human would.
Predictable lot sizing
At all times buying and selling 0.10 heaps? That is a sign. Calculated lot sizing based mostly on greenback threat and cease loss distance creates pure variation, completely different lot sizes on completely different trades relying on the setup.
Buying and selling throughout information occasions
Most EAs do not know when main information is occurring. They commerce proper by NFP and FOMC, and the ensuing worth motion appears to be like nothing like regular buying and selling. A built-in information filter avoids these home windows robotically.
No cooldown between trades
Human merchants do not instantly open a brand new place after closing one. They take a break, analyze the market, watch for the following setup. Cooldown timers between trades (30-60 minutes) replicate this pure habits.
The Guidelines for a Really Undetectable EA
Should you’re evaluating any EA for prop agency use, ask these questions:
- Does each consumer get a novel technique, or does everybody run the identical logic?
- Is the risk-to-reward ratio mounted or randomized?
- Does it embrace a information filter?
- Is there a cooldown between trades, or does it commerce continuous?
- Does it use martingale or grid? (Instantaneous purple flag for prop companies)
- Can the lot sizing differ naturally between trades?
- Does it commerce one place at a time, or stack a number of trades?
If the reply to most of those is “no”, your EA is a ticking time bomb. It’d work for some time. However ultimately, the sample exhibits up, and the account will get flagged.
The Backside Line
The period of operating any EA on a prop agency problem and getting away with it’s over.
Prop companies have the information. They’ve the instruments. And so they’re getting higher at sample detection each month.
The EAs that survive aren’t those with the most effective technique. They’re those that look completely different for each consumer.
1,000 technique combos. Randomized risk-to-reward. Information filter. Cooldown timers. One commerce at a time. No martingale. No grid.
That is not only a characteristic listing. That is what it takes to remain invisible.
I constructed the Prop Agency Hedge Grasp EA with all of those anti-detection options as a result of I wanted them myself, throughout 300+ challenges. It is now accessible on MQL5 Market together with the Prop Agency Hedge Reside EA for automated hedge execution.
If you wish to study extra about how the system works, verify my product web page or ship me a message.
