Subscribe right here: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | YouTube | Overcast | Pocket Casts
Yesterday, Jimmy Kimmel’s late-night present was suspended indefinitely. It’s a stunning second free of charge speech, given the order through which occasions unfolded. Earlier that day, FCC Chair Brendan Carr had urged on a conservative podcast that ABC and its associates contemplate taking steps in opposition to Kimmel, saying, “We are able to do that the straightforward manner or the exhausting manner.”
Because it so occurred, the late-night legend David Letterman was scheduled to talk at The Atlantic Competition the subsequent day. Letterman and The Atlantic’s editor in chief, Jeffrey Goldberg, sat down for an impromptu interview concerning the information. Right here’s their dialog.
The next is a transcript of the episode:
Hanna Rosin: The FCC has traditionally acted as a form of enforcer of group requirements. They’ve doled out fines for saying the F-word, for instance, or “wardrobe malfunctions.”
Factual errors, errors in judgment, unhealthy jokes—that has not historically been a part of their job, till this week. As you might have already heard, comic Jimmy Kimmel’s late-night present was suspended by ABC for feedback he made on the present concerning the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk.
Right here’s the timing of occasions, which is vital: Kimmel says one thing inaccurate concerning the man who killed Charlie Kirk. Shortly after, the chairman of the FCC, Brendan Carr, will get on a right-wing podcast and means that ABC and its associates take steps in opposition to Kimmel, saying, quote, “We are able to do that the straightforward manner or the exhausting manner.”
The community, which depends on stations carrying their programming, wasted little time. That very same day, they pulled Kimmel’s exhibit the air indefinitely. Right here’s what Trump mentioned when a reporter requested him about it on Air Pressure One.
President Donald Trump: I learn someplace that the networks have been 97 % in opposition to me. I acquired 97 % unfavorable, and but I received it simply. I received all seven swing states, the favored vote. I received every part.
And in the event that they’re 97 % in opposition to, they provide me solely unhealthy publicity or press. I imply, they’re getting a license. I’d assume perhaps their license needs to be taken away. It will be as much as Brendan Carr.
Rosin: I’m Hanna Rosin. That is Radio Atlantic. On Thursday, Atlantic Editor in Chief Jeffrey Goldberg sat down with precisely the particular person you wish to hear from about what it signifies that the federal government is weighing in on whether or not comedians who do political comedy could make a barely mistaken, mediocre joke.
Retired Late Present host David Letterman could have very nicely invented or a minimum of perfected the style of pushing the political envelope for late-night tv. They spoke at The Atlantic Competition on the heels of a dialog with playwright Ayad Akhtar about artwork and AI.
Listed here are Goldberg and Letterman.
[Audience applause]
Jeffrey Goldberg: Simply so that you perceive, as , David Letterman was coming to do an interview right here, however given the occasions of the final 18 hours or so, we requested him if he would come out slightly bit early and discuss to me concerning the occasions of the final night time. So David Letterman is gonna come out, and Ayad is gonna swap locations with him. Thanks, Ayad.
Girls and gents, David Letterman.
David Letterman: How are you doing? Good to fulfill you. Thanks very a lot. Thanks.
[Audience applause]
Letterman: Wait a minute. I hoped there’d be a second wave. You’re all proper.
Goldberg: (Laughs.)
Letterman: Good to see you.
Goldberg: Yeah. Yeah. Thanks for doing this.
Letterman: I used to be gonna discuss concerning the playwright within the age of AI. What the hell?
Goldberg: Yeah. Yeah, I do know, I do know. We completely flipped the script on you. I’m sorry. I’m simply gonna keep out right here for a couple of minutes and discuss to you about it, and then you definitely’re gonna interview your visitor. However look, we noticed what occurred final night time. It follows what occurred to [Stephen] Colbert. You’re the godfather of the style.
Letterman: Sure, I’m.
Goldberg: Yeah. You’re the godfather of the style.
Letterman: The nice-grandfather.
Goldberg: Inform us—I wasn’t going there. Inform us what you consider what occurred final night time to Jimmy Kimmel.
Letterman: Effectively, it is a distress. And on this planet of someone who’s an authoritarian—perhaps a dictatorship—in the end, everybody goes to be touched.
However that is me for 30 years. I did this for a residing. So I see this occur—they took care of Colbert. That was impolite. That was inexcusable. The person deserves quite a lot of credit score. He’s within the corridor of fame 9 instances. And to be manipulated like that as a result of the Ellison household didn’t wish to bother Donald Trump with this transfer, in order that they removed him—not solely removed him, removed the entire franchise. You’re not gonna have to fret about something, Larry. It’s all gone. It’s effective. Goodnight.
After which my good buddy Jimmy Kimmel, , I simply really feel unhealthy about this as a result of all of us see the place that is going, right? It’s managed media.
And it’s no good. It’s foolish. It’s ridiculous. You may’t go round firing someone since you are fearful or making an attempt to suck as much as an authoritarian, legal administration within the Oval Workplace. That’s simply not how this works.
[Audience applause]
Letterman: 10 years in the past, I used to be sensible sufficient to cancel myself. However the different factor is: The FCC, this man—
Goldberg: Brendan Carr.
Letterman: —Brendan Carr, sure. So this man on the FCC says: We are able to do issues the straightforward manner. We are able to do issues the exhausting manner. Who’s hiring these goons? Mario Puzo?
The FCC: We’re not blissful till you aren’t blissful, for God’s sakes. After I was a child, I used to be, like, 20 years previous and I wished to work at a radio station, so I went to Chicago, to the FCC. You are taking a check, you go the check, you might have your Third Telephone radio-broadcasting license.
That’s what the FCC does. In the event you’re a 50,000-watt clear-channel radio station, annually they’ll come and examine your dials to be sure you’re not broadcasting at 55,000 watts. And God forbid you’re, then you definitely get an $8 effective. That’s the FCC. I don’t know what’s going on right here.
Goldberg: Let me ask you this. You labored by 5 – 6 presidential administrations.
Letterman: Oh my god. And sure, a complete checklist. It began with Jimmy Carter.
Goldberg: Your first present within the Carter period?
Letterman: Sure, that’s proper. After which all the best way proper up by Barack Obama. And was there one after that that I labored for? When did I go away?
Goldberg: Presumably, I don’t know personally. When did you—10 years in the past, you mentioned?
Letterman: Cling on, I acquired an inventory. Jimmy Carter, Ronald Reagan, George Bush senior, Invoice Clinton, George Bush II, Barack Obama. Yeah. All proper.
And attacked these males mercilessly. By no means as soon as—nicely, Jimmy Carter not a lot. What are you able to say about Jimmy Carter? He was only a candy man. However everyone else we actually went to work on. And I can keep in mind, Invoice Clinton we actually went to work on, after which it acquired so it was like, Whoa, it is a reward. What are we gonna do? Invoice Clinton, he’s out of workplace after eight years of Invoice Clinton. After which George Bush got here alongside, and it was straightforward motoring after that.
However the level is: Beating up on these individuals, rightly or wrongly, precisely or maybe inaccurately, within the title of comedy, not as soon as have been we squeezed by anybody from any governmental company, not to mention the dreaded FCC.
Goldberg: Republican, Democrat. By no means a—
Letterman: Effectively, I’ll say we most likely went straightforward on Barack Obama as a result of I kinda just like the man.
Goldberg: However by no means a name from the White Home?
Letterman: Nothing.
Goldberg: By no means an intimation?
Letterman: No. As a result of everyone kind of understood—within the title of humor, within the title of commenting on what’s occurring on this planet, cultural occasions—why not?
And by the best way, the establishment of the president of the USA should be greater than a man doing a chat present. , it simply—it actually should be greater.
[Audience applause]
Goldberg: Effectively, it was actually attention-grabbing: Final night time, late at night time, Trump is tweeting or Fact Socialing from Windsor Fort after a state dinner hosted by the king of England, doing his late-night tv present critique. It appears like we’re residing in a simulation when you consider that.
Letterman: Effectively, it will be hilarious if it wasn’t all resulting in one thing from which we received’t recuperate.
Goldberg: What do you assume it’s resulting in?
Letterman: Effectively, to begin with, right here’s the factor that’s up my nostril nowadays. By God, we gotta get to work on these midterms. Effectively, I feel the midterm elections can be elections in title solely. I’m sorry. The Republicans have raised untold billions of {dollars}. The Democrats, I feel, are staggering a bit behind by way of fundraising.
Goldberg: Let me ask you concerning the precise joke or commentary that Jimmy Kimmel made the opposite night time. It truly was inaccurate.
Letterman: So what?
Goldberg: I imply, recognizing that he’s a comic, not a journalist.
Letterman: Sure, precisely proper. All of us make errors. I imply, good Lord. And by the best way, the situation of the USA of America has not been good from the time I used to be born to this very day, and earlier than that. We all know that. The objective isn’t perfection.
Errors are gonna be made. Hopefully it would enhance. I feel, sadly, it’s not going to enhance. I’m not precisely, in full thoughts, understanding of what Jimmy mentioned, what he was making an attempt to say, and what mistake was made. That is one thing that was predicted by our president proper after Stephen Colbert acquired walked off. So that you’re telling me that this isn’t premeditated at some stage?
Goldberg: Effectively, I imply, he additionally introduced that Jimmy Fallon and Seth Meyers have been subsequent.
Letterman: (Laughs.) Jesus.
Goldberg: And Jimmy Fallon—that is my very own view—isn’t fairly as sharp-tongued as—
Letterman: And why is that, Jeff? Why do you assume that’s? Has one thing to do with IQ, is that what you’re saying?
Goldberg: (Laughs.) He has a special character. He’s only a totally different form of comic.
Letterman: By the best way, isn’t this man nice on Friday nights?
[Audience applause]
Goldberg: Have a look at that. Thanks very a lot.
Letterman: Me and my grandparents actually love him.
Goldberg: (Laughs.) I instructed him he’s manner too younger to look at Washington Week with The Atlantic. However—
Letterman: , when this factor occurred final night time. And by the best way, I’ve heard from Jimmy—he was good sufficient to textual content me this morning—and he’s sitting up in mattress, taking nourishment. He’s gonna be effective.
[Audience laughter]
Letterman: However I mentioned to my spouse, I mentioned, “I don’t know what to assume or say about this case. I want on this planet,” and that is what’s nice about New York, “I want on this planet I might discuss to Jeff Goldberg.” Right here I’m speaking to Jeff Goldberg. I imply, sincere to God, isn’t it superb how these items work?
Goldberg: It’s all serendipity right here. However maintain occurring this theme of this dissent, as a result of one of many issues I feel loads of us are questioning about—I’m shocked on the variety of hard-core strikes that this administration has made in lots of, many various instructions directly, together with dismantling the CDC, as only one instance. Dismantling USAID. In each route.
Letterman: You don’t just like the labor numbers, you fireplace the particular person studying the labor numbers.
Goldberg: So the query is, it does appear—and I simply need your evaluation of this—it does appear that there’s a form of passivity within the nation about these items. Persons are saying, Effectively, Jimmy Kimmel did—I imply, I’ve to ask you that query—however Jimmy Kimmel did get it mistaken. So, within the firm—we heard Mike Pence earlier say, Effectively, look, it’s a non-public firm. Jimmy Kimmel doesn’t have a First Modification proper to work for that firm. He didn’t precisely cope with the query of the strain placed on by the FCC.
However what’s your prognosis? What’s the pink line for the American individuals, who I’ve believed like having a First Modification, traditionally and right this moment.
Letterman: Oh, actually? You assume so? Sure. I feel it’s served us.
Goldberg: I imply, I’ve all the time operated underneath the belief that individuals assume it’s fairly good which you could get to say what you need in America.
Letterman: Sure. Sure.
Goldberg: So what’s going on right here?
Letterman: Effectively, I’d ask you, what are the figuring out landmarks right here? Authoritarianism. How is that totally different from a dictatorship? Does authoritarianism breed dictators? Is dictator a particular class? The place are we on that progress? As a result of I feel we’re inexorably headed in that route. So I would like you to inform me one thing encouraging that I can take residence that may cool down my spouse.
Goldberg: You’re not—this isn’t rhetorical. You’re a—
Letterman: I’m asking you.
Goldberg: Oh, you’re—ah, shit.
Letterman: (Laughs.) He mentioned “shit”! Oh my God. The Atlantic Month-to-month man mentioned “shit”! Sure! There’s your First Modification, women and gents.
[Audience applause]
Goldberg: Thanks very a lot. Thanks. Thanks. (Laughs.) No, as I mentioned to Ayad, we don’t have to fret concerning the FCC.
Look, we don’t fear, I imply—and I’ve to say this in all seriousness to a gaggle of people that subscribe to The Atlantic and skim The Atlantic. Look, , there’s solely two methods to method. I’m not making an attempt to sound, like, self-righteous or no matter. I’m not. There’s solely two methods to method this second: Both you keep true to your mission and simply say what you assume is true—what to be true—otherwise you don’t.
I’m personally very shocked on the giant numbers of firms that don’t should fold. It’s nearly cash. I imply, no person, but, is threatening to ship them to the gulag. However the pursuit of cash has distorted the reactions of the individuals who know higher, together with the individuals who make use of Jimmy Kimmel and Stephen Colbert—and, by the best way, a newspaper that’s based mostly in Washington that we are able to discuss at one other time.
Letterman: What occurred to that rag?
[Audience laughter]
Goldberg: , there are solely two sorts of householders. I imply, we occur to have a superb one. However there’s two sorts of householders, they usually’re the homeowners who don’t notice that their one accountability is to guard the journalists, to permit them to say precisely—the entire nation is constructed on this premise. We don’t—
Letterman: However that is precisely what I’m alluding to. There was these two requirements of journalism in the USA, the Put up and the Occasions. And one might assume: Okay, these will stabilize. These are individuals who symbolize the reality, and in the event that they get it mistaken, they apologize and can make modifications. And now one is gone.
I’ve members of the family who stay within the Washington, D.C., space. And also you’re fortunate in case you get the crossword and climate, , out of The Washington Put up.
Goldberg: To reply your query briefly, there isn’t any reply. What’s the shiny line between delicate authoritarianism, preemptive authoritarianism?
Letterman: Sure.
Goldberg: By the best way, the analogy of the boiling frog is definitely incorrect. Frogs do attempt to hop out of water, it seems.
Letterman: Effectively, lastly, we’ve discovered one thing right here right this moment.
[Audience laughter]
Goldberg: However day-after-day brings this nearly cognitive assault.
Letterman: How do individuals—you assume: Okay, I’m nonetheless okay. I can nonetheless have breakfast. I nonetheless have a big-screen TV. So issues are okay. At what level do individuals who needs to be affected by this as early on, when—and once more, issues weren’t good for an enormous a part of this nation, they usually’re not gonna get higher for that very same group. So at what level do the doorways open within the thoughts of common People they usually’re petrified?
Goldberg: The issue is: So long as there are an abundance of low-cost energy, moderately priced gasoline, and infinite video diversion, it’s very exhausting to think about this nation proper now kind of saying, Wait a second—having a functioning CDC, FDA, USAID, Nationwide Climate Service, etcetera.
That is the principle query that I ask, and I feel loads of our journalists of The Atlantic ask, is, like: When is that this gonna penetrate? When is the concept—like, we’ve all the time believed that vaccination was a settled situation in America, for the reason that time of George Washington, as I discussed earlier.
It seems that it’s not settled. That doesn’t appear to upset individuals sufficient.
Letterman: I do know. That is the nice thriller. Why aren’t individuals upset by this or a half-dozen different issues which might be upsetting?
Goldberg: However you what? Perhaps it’s like—and I’m not evaluating anybody nation to a different nation—however perhaps it’s like Tahrir Sq. in Cairo in 2011: No one thought that it was gonna occur till it occurred. And I don’t know what the factor is.
Letterman: That is the Arab Spring.
Goldberg: The Arab Spring, sure. I don’t know what the factor is. You’ll assume that it’s when the federal government fires the individuals who monitor Ebola, which isn’t a partisan situation. You’ll assume that many individuals would say: what? It’s most likely higher to know the place the Ebola is.
And that hasn’t occurred. So we’re all ready to see what the response is, however we additionally perceive that individuals within the Trump administration—
Letterman: Okay, so let’s simply say there may be an consciousness—
Goldberg: By the best way, I do know that we have now to, like, convey out your precise visitor.
Letterman: I’m calling the photographs right here, pal.
[Audience laughter]
Letterman: However let’s simply say there may be an precise consciousness past what you and I consider and may think about. Let’s say everyone is conscious. What will we do?
Goldberg: Effectively, look, we nonetheless have a free media. I imply, we get to say—
Letterman: Can we?
Goldberg: Yeah. Effectively, giant swaths of it, yeah. The world’s largest newspaper, The New York Occasions, is impartial of what’s taking place in Washington.
Letterman: What number of instances has the president sued them?
Goldberg: I perceive that they’re underneath strain, however once more, it comes again to—
Letterman: Effectively, have a look at what occurred to The Washington Put up with their homeowners.
Goldberg: Effectively, precisely. No. I’m not saying we’re not in bother.
Letterman: I imply, thank God in your journal.
Goldberg: Thank God. Sure.
[Audience applause]
Goldberg: That’s worthy of a pause. And look, we have now an impartial judiciary. What we don’t have proper now could be a legislative department that’s functioning in line with the calls for of the Structure. That’s the largest troublesome truth. However we do have an impartial judiciary.
Letterman: However will you agree that checks and balances have—they’re fairly anemic now?
Goldberg: I agree that every part is underneath strain proper now. And in the end, and look, coming again to the Mike Pence interview earlier than—and I hear loads of issues about Mike Pence, and I perceive there are lots of people who disagree with Mike Pence and his worldview. I’d say this: Typically an individual’s complete life will be judged by what they do in a single single second of their life.
Mike Pence mentioned on that horrible day: Nope, this election—this was a free and honest election. The outcomes needs to be ratified. I don’t care that the one who made me vp desires to kill me. I’m going to do my constitutional obligation.
And I’ve this hope and I feel you do too. Perhaps you don’t.
Letterman: I don’t.
Goldberg: Effectively, all proper, effective.
[Audience laughter]
Letterman: I’m sorry. I don’t.
Goldberg: I’ve this hope that there are numerous, many extra individuals like Mike Pence. We haven’t seen sufficient of them within the present manifestation of the—
Letterman: What are they ready on?
Goldberg: That’s the query.
Letterman: And by the best way, I’ll converse for everyone on this room who has children. I don’t a lot care about me. I’ve had my enjoyable. I acquired a 21-year-old son. I’m nervous about him and his household.
Goldberg: And that’s utterly professional. And I’m now, I’m gonna go away you so you are able to do—
Letterman: It’s been enjoyable, although, proper?
Goldberg: Yeah, no, it’s been nice. I respect it. Thanks for coming to The Atlantic Competition.
Letterman: It is a nice pleasure for me. Thanks very a lot.
Goldberg: It’s nice. And now you will introduce your visitor. Thanks very a lot.
[Audience applause, music]
Rosin: This episode of Radio Atlantic was produced by Kevin Townsend. It was edited by Claudine Ebeid. Sam Fentress truth checked. Rob Smierciak engineered and offered authentic music. Claudine Ebeid is the manager producer of Atlantic audio, and Andrea Valdez is our managing editor.
Listeners, you’ll be able to watch and hearken to extra from The Atlantic Competition by visiting TheAtlantic.com/Competition.
And in case you like what you hear on Radio Atlantic, you’ll be able to help our work and the work of all Atlantic journalists once you subscribe to The Atlantic at TheAtlantic.com/Listener. I’m Hanna Rosin. Thanks for listening.
